Raising Elves

As wild as nature. Myself, parenting and natural remedies blog.

Extreme parenting: Evidence based practises

7 Comments

I’m a research fiend and I’m all for evidence being taken into consideration when making decisions.

To a degree.

I must admit, the title to this post is a little provocative but I’ve had some thoughts lately based on some responses about parenting and breastfeeding queries on online forums that I am on.

Of course it’s in the minority where sometimes the loudest voices are found. Zealous about informing you, as if you haven’t read it all yourself.

You get this in every walk of life but in regards to parenting the theme I find most common is ‘evidence says this’.

The thing about evidence in this topic is that the complexity of human physiology and psychology is not an exact science.

So although some evidence based results would recommend following a certain approach, it is not the be all and end all. It is not the only way. It is OK to try something else if your baby does not respond to an evidence based approach. (It goes without saying that I am obviously excluding abuse here but I’ll say it anyway.)

I think if we get all wrapped up in expert opinion we lose our intuition and in my opinion, intuition, or instinct if you prefer, is incredibly important in parenting.

Don’t get me wrong, research is important too. To an extent it’s good to have a few parenting experts out there, although maybe the industry needs to be regulated. Our civilisation has come a long way with expert opinion (think corporal punishment as one example).

One thing I find hardest is to watch parents ask questions about a decision they have come to and have people throw links at them telling them about how wrong their decision is.

It is all from a good intention, of course but not always appropriate or empathic.

Do you know how hard it is to put yourself out there as a parent? To come out and say that despite evidence you are doing something differently?

It’s hard.

In my limited experience, it seems most other folks are doing something similar- just trying to do a good job of it. Some of the best parents I know never even read one book.

It is the extreme voices that seem to quote ‘evidence’ as scripture and although they are actually quite rare, I find that online their tone of voice can be quite severe when getting a point across. This can be very isolating to a parent who is looking for help.

I think a more balanced approach would be helpful and if a person asks a question, try answer the question. If you can’t answer the question or disagree with the topic then don’t respond unless the person is asking for opinions.

Respect the intelligence of other parents. Most likely they know what the evidence says but are trying something different because evidence doesn’t work for them.

Parents already hassle themselves enough, they don’t need anybody else to do it for them. They need support.

Let’s respect the diversity of parenting.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Extreme parenting: Evidence based practises

  1. Here, here Laura! You know I’m all about the evidence based research too but I’m really more interested in informed choice! Many, many times I’ve read the research, known what the recommendations were and in my heart of hearts have made the right decision for me and my family. I like when people post the links to things I’m looking information about so I can learn more but I hate the example you’re talking about, when they’re posted to ram it down someone else’s throat. Bad form!

    Parenting experts, don’t get me started! I stopped reading parenting books before my little man turned one. All they did was made me feel terrible and gave me information about nothing useful. While we’re talking about evidence, I actually find that most parenting books or experts mention either! Everything seems to be from their own personal experience and therefore a blanket rule for us all.

    Sorry! Went on a bit there 🙂

    Great post.

  2. Here, here! You know I’m all about the evidence based research too but I’m really more interested in informed choice! Many, many times I’ve read the research, known what the recommendations were and in my heart of hearts have made the right decision for me and my family. I like when people post the links to things I’m looking information about so I can learn more but I hate the example you’re talking about, when they’re posted to ram it down someone else’s throat. Bad form!

    Parenting experts, don’t get me started! I stopped reading parenting books before my little man turned one. All they did was made me feel terrible and gave me information about nothing useful. While we’re talking about evidence, I actually find that most parenting books or experts mention either! Everything seems to be from their own personal experience and therefore a blanket rule for us all.

    Sorry! Went on a bit there 🙂

    Great post.

  3. Good topic for discussion. I find it somewhat amusing how the people with the most zealous opinions actually seem to think they’re going to change someone’s mind by lecturing them on a topic. I think people are far more open to considering a different opinion if they’re approached in a reasonable way, and it’s understood that it’s their choice if they want to disagree and continue with whatever they wanted to do. Doesn’t matter how good your evidence is, if the person you’re talking to has stopped listening due to your attitude!

  4. Brilliant Laura. Just **brilliant**

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s